Pokemon Server Archive

Community Related => General Discussion => Debates => Topic started by: hobo4chompy on March 14, 2013, 03:45:32 am

Title: Red's Death on Mt Silver True Or did he just walk away after you defeated him
Post by: hobo4chompy on March 14, 2013, 03:45:32 am

Shark and I where Having this Discussion (Fight) About the Topic and i want to know your Opinion on this The story that i believe is is Under

Red was sent to Mt. Silver not to train his Pokemon, but as a place of solitude. To escape the mental anguish Kanto had brought him.
Oak congratulating him on his victory over his grandson Blue was just a front for the media. Behind the scenes, Oak scolded Red for de-throwning his grandson as champion. Even Red's mother eventually supported Oak's opinion and ruled her son as cruel and heartless for doing such a thing to Blue, especially after he killed his Raticate.Word of what Red had done spread quickly throughout Kanto. Everyone began to hate him for what he did to poor Blue. The death of his Pokemon and denying him a championship.Eventually, all of Kanto hated Red. Red quickly grew emotionally unstable from such abuse. He didn't have friends anymore. They all hated him, even his mother, because of what he did to Blue. In an act of trying to free himself from this region-wide torment, Red ran away to Mt. Silver so he could forever live in peace and solitude with his Pokemon and escape the constant torment the people of Kanto put him through.

His only friends at that point were his Pokemon.Red eventually died atop Mt. Silver. The freezing cold claimed the lives of him and his Pokemon. Although many people detest this theory, the facts are there. Notice how when you battle Red as Gold/Ethan, he simply disappears after the battle. Without a trace. This was possible because he's in fact a ghost that basically forced himself into death being all of Kanto mentally tormented him ever since he defeated Blue for the League Championship. Notice how he doesn't say anything upon your encounter with him. His soul was too disturbed by the tormenting happenings that occurred in Kanto prior to his championship. Too unstable to say a word. Oh how it must feel to have your own mother resent your very existence...Red found out the hard way that becoming a champion was not what it was cracked up to be. It was not only the direct cause of his eventual mental instabilities, but also the first step in his demise; His death atop Mt. Silver.


This is my Story and im sticking with it. Also that When you beat Red He Dissapears. You dont accualy see him walk away
so im asking you guys what do you believe He walked away or he died on my silver and Was a Ghost until he got beaten and Departed for the After Life.
Title: Re: Red's Death on Mt Silver True Or did he just walk away after you defeated him
Post by: ArchieSalt on March 14, 2013, 12:52:09 pm
This is the most ridiculous story ever. But you've got me interested. I'm going to find out what REALLY happens to Red. Even if it kills me
Title: Re: Red's Death on Mt Silver True Or did he just walk away after you defeated him
Post by: Pythonhier on March 14, 2013, 03:25:39 pm
That.... That was the worst... not best thing ever.  See what I did there?  This was awesome!  I love the idea.  I always just assumed that when you went up top to fight Red he was up there training, and he just attacks you for trespassing without a word, and when you win he gets "Run's to the nearest Pokemon center".  But this is much more awesome!
Title: Re: Red's Death on Mt Silver True Or did he just walk away after you defeated him
Post by: Frenzy_Monkey47 on March 14, 2013, 05:15:38 pm
Hm I know it's true Red Killed Blues ugly rat thing but I think this isn't true at all.
Title: Re: Red's Death on Mt Silver True Or did he just walk away after you defeated him
Post by: Barnitzn on March 14, 2013, 05:45:37 pm
I would agree with you in some cases, except for two things

1. Pokemon doesn't kill anything, you don't even know if Raticate died, we are just speculating that

2. Red has Gary's Charizard and I don't think that he would give it to him over what had happened in the championship fight
Title: Re: Red's Death on Mt Silver True Or did he just walk away after you defeated him
Post by: Frenzy_Monkey47 on March 14, 2013, 06:52:43 pm
It does
In lavender town Blue states "Red did you ever have a pokemon die?''
After that raticate was never on his team again.
Title: Re: Red's Death on Mt Silver True Or did he just walk away after you defeated him
Post by: Okieskinny on March 14, 2013, 07:57:26 pm
Red didn't directly kill Raticate I believe, instead I think Raticate died from drowning, as the S.S. Anne was extremely crowded, and Raticate could have been shoved off the side of the ship.
Title: Re: Red's Death on Mt Silver True Or did he just walk away after you defeated him
Post by: hobo4chompy on March 15, 2013, 09:25:30 am
Ok so with Raticattes Death


Red vsd Blue on S.S Anne
Red Beat Blue on the S.S Anne


Then Blue tried to hurry to a Pokemon Center But there was no Pokemon center on the S.S Anne and since it was Crowded Blue couldnt Make it in time


Thus Ratticates death
Title: Re: Red's Death on Mt Silver True Or did he just walk away after you defeated him
Post by: ryancpexpert on March 30, 2013, 10:29:00 pm
i think what happened was he had 7 pokemon the seventh one use some type of move that would blend them with the scenery and he hurried off to continue training without accepting defeat from you.
Title: Re: Red's Death on Mt Silver True Or did he just walk away after you defeated him
Post by: Z4X3R on March 31, 2013, 04:12:43 am
Ffs Ryan stop bumping all of these useless threads.